calender_icon.png 20 November, 2026 | 2:19 AM

Rs 2 lakh compensation in encounter death case

20-11-2026 12:00:00 AM

Justice Suddala Chalapathi Rao of the Telangana High Court directed the State to pay Rs. 2 lakh compensation to the widow of a man killed in an alleged police encounter in Medak district in 2001. The judge held that the police failed to follow the guidelines issued by the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) governing encounter deaths.

The judge further observed that the State cannot justify a death caused in police firing merely by claiming self-defence without producing cogent material establishing the circumstances of the incident. The judge was dealing with a writ petition filed by Ponna Venkatamma, challenging the alleged killing of her husband, B. Balanarsaiah, on December 11, 2001, at Chetla Thimmayapalli village in Chegunta Mandal, Medak district.

The petitioner sought registration of a criminal case against the then Sub-Inspector of Police, Kishen Singh, an independent investigation into the incident and compensation of Rs. 2 lakh for herself and her children.

The petitioner contended that her husband, a small farmer, was falsely implicated in a case relating to the abduction of a police Sub-Inspector by members of the outlawed Peoples War Group in October 2001. She alleged that her husband was preparing to surrender before the police with the assistance of a local political leader when police personnel approached him near a toddy shop on December 11, 2001, and shot him dead.

She further alleged that the police subsequently portrayed the killing as an encounter involving extremists. Opposing the writ petition, the police authorities maintained that Balanarsaiah was a member of the outlawed Peoples War Group and that police personnel opened fire in self-defence after extremists allegedly fired at them. The State submitted that a criminal case was registered in connection with the incident and that a magisterial enquiry was ordered.

Counsel for the petitioner, Vasudha Nagaraj, argued that the authorities failed to comply with the NHRC guidelines requiring registration of a case and an independent investigation into encounter deaths. She relied on judgments of the Supreme Court concerning extrajudicial killings, the right to life and the obligation of the State to ensure accountability in police encounters.

The judge observed that the NHRC guidelines issued in 1997 were already in force when the incident occurred and required encounter deaths to be investigated by an independent agency, such as the State Crime Investigation Department, rather than officers of the same police station. The judge pointed out that although the authorities claimed that a Revenue Divisional Officer was appointed to conduct an enquiry, no material was produced to establish that the enquiry was completed or to disclose its findings.

The judge observed that the State failed to substantiate its claim of self-defence through any investigation or supporting evidence. Referring to Article 21 of the Constitution, the judge held that no person could be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to the procedure established by law. The judge further observed that the guidelines governing encounter deaths were binding on the authorities and that the failure to follow the prescribed procedure could not be overlooked.

The judge held that the State and police authorities were liable to compensate the petitioner for the death of her husband, as the claim of self-defence remained unsupported by cogent evidence and the mandatory procedure was not followed. Accordingly, the judge partly allowed the writ petition and directed the respondents to pay the compensation.